Focus & ADHD
Coffee Shop Noise for Focus: Does It Work, and How to Get It at Home
A café is loud, and plenty of people still get more done there than at home. Here is what that blur of sound does, who it suits, and how to recreate it.
Sleep
Fireplace sounds are one of the most played cozy recordings online. Here is what they do well, where they get in the way, and how to set one up for reading, work or bed.
Fireplace sounds are the hiss, settle and pop of burning wood, played from a phone instead of a hearth. People play them to read, to work and to fall asleep. We could find no trial for any of those uses.
No one knows. The likeliest reason is plain association: a fire means you are indoors and warm and the day is over, and the recording borrows that feeling.
A fire is also never steady: a low roar, a hiss, an occasional pop. A guess: it is busy enough that your mind does not go looking for something else, and wordless enough that it does not compete with a page. Nobody has tested that for fire. Rain has the same quality, which is why the two are often grouped. A small 2017 study (Gould van Praag and colleagues) found that naturalistic sounds left people more outward-focused than artificial ones, though it tested nature sounds in general. Fire, sleep and work were not part of it.
We found no trial of fireplace sounds for focus or sleep. The closest is a set of three studies by the anthropologist Christopher Lynn on fire and blood pressure. In Lynn’s words, as quoted by Improbable Research, he found “significant reductions in blood pressure associated with fire with a naturalistic auditory component”, and no significant effect when people watched a flickering fire with the sound removed. In that work the sound mattered; watching flames without it did not move blood pressure.
That is one group’s blood pressure result, and we only saw it through a summary, so we do not know how many people were tested. Treat it as a reason to try a fire, not as evidence that it works for focus or sleep.
When the pops are sharp. A loud snap can drag you off the sentence you were reading. At night it is worse, since sudden sounds tend to cause brief awakenings in noise research (Basner and colleagues, 2014, a review of environmental noise, not fire pops).
Recordings differ a lot. A microphone close to a hot fire gives loud, sharp cracks. A farther, softer mix gives a hiss with the odd muffled tick. Play ten seconds of any recording at the volume you will actually use before you commit to it, and skip it if you flinch.
A fire also does a poor job as a mask. It is quiet and uneven, so it will not cover a neighbor’s TV or traffic. For that, use a steady sound such as brown noise.
A fire suits work without words in it: reading, planning, journaling, clearing email. It is a worse pick for debugging or close proofreading, where rain or brown noise is easier to ignore. If you are after the feeling of working somewhere with atmosphere, coffee shop noise is the same idea with voices in it.
Start with the volume low enough that you cannot pick out single pops from across the room. If you can follow a crackle with your eyes closed, it is too loud for work. Pick one recording and keep it for the whole session, because changing tracks is a distraction of its own.
To find out whether it beats your usual sound, work on similar tasks for three 50-minute blocks with the fire and three with brown noise, alternating days, and write down how many pages or tasks you finish. One session settles nothing, because your sleep, caffeine and workload change from day to day more than the sound does.
Set it so you have to listen for it, around a quarter of your usual volume, and put it on a timer. If you play a video instead, turn the screen off or dim it fully, since a lit screen by the bed works against you. If you only need help dropping off, 30 to 60 minutes is enough, and the fade-out means you are not woken by the silence or by a pop at 3 a.m. Leave it on all night only if noise comes back later, such as a street or a neighbor.
Steady rain underneath should soften the contrast when a crack comes, since the jump from quiet to loud is smaller. Nobody has tested that with fire. Give a new sound several nights before you decide. That is a rule of thumb, not a tested figure, but the first night or two mostly tell you it is unfamiliar. If a pop does wake you, lower the fire or drop it and keep the rain or brown noise. The same trade-offs apply to storms and surf, which are covered in thunderstorm sounds for sleep.
Solbox has a Crackling Fire sound in its sleep sounds, described in the app as the slow pop and hiss of a wood fire. It comes with Solbox Pro. You can layer it with a free noise such as brown noise or Gentle Rain, each with its own volume, so the fire sits low and the steady sound carries the room. The sleep timer goes up to 8 hours 55 minutes and fades the mix out at the end, and the Pomodoro timer runs with the same sounds for a work block.
It is one fire recording, so you cannot choose a distant or close mix. If a fire sound is all you want, free videos and web players do the job. The app is worth it if you want a quiet fire over rain, with one timer that fades both out together.
Solbox is a sound app, not a medical device. Fireplace sounds are not a treatment for ADHD, insomnia or any other condition. If poor sleep lasts for weeks, talk to a doctor.
Some people fall asleep more easily with them, but we found no trial of fireplace sounds and sleep. Research on environmental noise finds that sudden sounds are what tend to cause brief awakenings, so a recording with sharp pops may work against you. Keep it quiet and put it on a fade-out timer.
They may for reading, planning and routine work, since they have no words to compete with the page. No study has tested fire sounds against other background sounds for focus. If the pops pull your attention, try brown noise or rain instead.
Neither has been shown to be better. White noise is steadier and covers speech more evenly. A fire is more varied and many people find it more pleasant. Alternate them for a few sessions and keep the one you notice less.
Only if your room has noise that comes back through the night. If you only need help falling asleep, a fade-out timer of 30 to 60 minutes is enough.
The Crackling Fire sound comes with Solbox Pro. Brown noise and Gentle Rain are free and make a good steady base for it.